This one is going to be dark. It's going to be heavy. It's going to be astoundingly personal. It is going to be hard for me to write, but, I'm going to do it anyway.
You don't have to read it. I will completely understand. It may actually be a relief if you don't.
I wrote it last night and had to sleep on it before posting it.
Here goes...
Yesterday afternoon my mother called me to let me know my dad had died.
Now, before you rush to check in on me or express sympathy for my loss I'd like to clarify some very important things.
My mother left my father a long LONG time ago.
My father was an asshole.
I haven't suffered a great loss.
Or maybe I have, but it certainly wasn't the corporeal form of the man I grew up calling Dad.
I have been carrying such a weird weighted feeling since she told me. I just can't seem to sort out my emotions. I feel grief and a sadness that is unexpected.
Don Ira Hirsch was a bastard. He was mean. He was abusive. He was a master of the mind fuck and the subtle bruise.
He would say awful shit to me. Words I still hear in my head. "You're worthless. Completely worthless." "Why can't you do anything right, EVER? You can't even wash the damn dishes!" and my personal favorite. "Nobody will ever love you, you know. You're fat and stupid and nobody loves girls like that." Sometimes they would be stage whispered in my ear. Sometimes screamed in my face. Sometimes barked like an order while he made me suck in my stomach and push it out over and over again in some bizarre ritual that was supposed to help me lose weight while gaining shame.
Sometimes he would hit me. Sometimes he would grab my arms and shake me so hard he'd leave finger print bruises. His favorite weapon of choice, though, was his belt. Lord have mercy if you heard him undo his buckle or the "vvvvvvvwwwip" sound of it pulling through the belt loops.
As a kid, I didn't understand. I couldn't wrap my mind around the idea that this man who was SUPPOSED to love me just... didn't. I thought that someday he'd change and be my dad. Someday I'd be good enough to warrant it.
I remember the moment I realized that was never going to happen. A friends older brother hurt me. He had jammed my head between the mattress and the headboard of his parent's bed and the pressure had made me pass out. I told Don about it expecting... hoping... that he would be upset. This was it! A chance for him to dad-up and defend his little girl. I knew, I just KNEW in my heart that this was the moment where he'd knight-in-shining armor and scoop me somewhere safe and rush over to the kid's parent's and they'd talk and whatever it is grownups do. I'd have the dad that everybody on TV seemed to have.
Instead he asked me if I liked it and then smacked me when I sarcastically answered "Yeah, dad. It was great."
I was pretty disappointed in his response. But it was a lesson I needed to learn.
In retrospect, the worst was that he loved to try to make me hate my sister almost as much as he loved to make me hate myself. He would do everything in his power to separate us. To divide us. To let me know JUST how much he loved her and JUST how little he cared about me. He doted on her... she had a room, and dolls and books and a canopy bed (SO jelly). I had a dusty couch, whatever I brought with me from moms, and a couple of trinkets that he had been forced to purchase.
I don't know how much my sister remembers. She was so little and he hid his dark side from her. I've never asked her and, Dudie... if you are reading this... I never will. I don't want to compare notes. All that matters is that I'm sorry we had to go through that. I love you so much. You are amazing and beautiful and wonderful and my heart would be lost without you. He didn't win. We did. It took a while, but WE WON.
All of this is ancient history. I'm not even sure why I'm writing about it. I haven't spoken to the man since I was in high school. I carry his scars, but I've dealt with most of my anger. I haven't even really thought about him in forever.
Yet... YEEEEET here I am. Struggling with a case of the feels.
I think if I hadn't passed the angry phase maybe I'd just feel happy. Fuck him. He's dead. Burn and rot and piss on your grave and all that, you fucker.
But, I don't. I don't feel happy he's dead. I feel vaguely sad.
My friend suggested today that I was sad because a spark of hope was now extinguished. That I'd kept it locked up tight, but, now that it was taken away from me I was feeling its loss.
My friend is not without smarts.
The truth is there are many reasons I'm feeling weird about this. I haven't had a chance to analyze all of them yet, and maybe I won't ever be able to. But the one I can see clearly is this: I'm sad because I will never get a dad. Not a real one. Not the kind I deserved. I'm sad because it's really truly over. There will be no reunion. He won't tell me he was wrong and that I AM amazing. The little girl in me will never have the dad who hugs and protects and loves her.
It's done. It's really over now.
And... as I've been writing this I've started to realize that can be okay.
My past shaped me. I wouldn't be who I am without it and, frankly, my life today is full of amazing people that I wouldn't trade for the world. The healing strength of the people who don't have to love me, but do far outweighs the pain of a man who was supposed to, but didn't. I am so grateful for that.
Yesterday afternoon my mother called me to let me know my dad had died.
Now, before you rush to check in on me or express sympathy for my loss I'd like to clarify some very important things.
My mother left my father a long LONG time ago.
My father was an asshole.
I haven't suffered a great loss.
Or maybe I have, but it certainly wasn't the corporeal form of the man I grew up calling Dad.
I have been carrying such a weird weighted feeling since she told me. I just can't seem to sort out my emotions. I feel grief and a sadness that is unexpected.
Don Ira Hirsch was a bastard. He was mean. He was abusive. He was a master of the mind fuck and the subtle bruise.
He would say awful shit to me. Words I still hear in my head. "You're worthless. Completely worthless." "Why can't you do anything right, EVER? You can't even wash the damn dishes!" and my personal favorite. "Nobody will ever love you, you know. You're fat and stupid and nobody loves girls like that." Sometimes they would be stage whispered in my ear. Sometimes screamed in my face. Sometimes barked like an order while he made me suck in my stomach and push it out over and over again in some bizarre ritual that was supposed to help me lose weight while gaining shame.
Sometimes he would hit me. Sometimes he would grab my arms and shake me so hard he'd leave finger print bruises. His favorite weapon of choice, though, was his belt. Lord have mercy if you heard him undo his buckle or the "vvvvvvvwwwip" sound of it pulling through the belt loops.
As a kid, I didn't understand. I couldn't wrap my mind around the idea that this man who was SUPPOSED to love me just... didn't. I thought that someday he'd change and be my dad. Someday I'd be good enough to warrant it.
I remember the moment I realized that was never going to happen. A friends older brother hurt me. He had jammed my head between the mattress and the headboard of his parent's bed and the pressure had made me pass out. I told Don about it expecting... hoping... that he would be upset. This was it! A chance for him to dad-up and defend his little girl. I knew, I just KNEW in my heart that this was the moment where he'd knight-in-shining armor and scoop me somewhere safe and rush over to the kid's parent's and they'd talk and whatever it is grownups do. I'd have the dad that everybody on TV seemed to have.
Instead he asked me if I liked it and then smacked me when I sarcastically answered "Yeah, dad. It was great."
I was pretty disappointed in his response. But it was a lesson I needed to learn.
In retrospect, the worst was that he loved to try to make me hate my sister almost as much as he loved to make me hate myself. He would do everything in his power to separate us. To divide us. To let me know JUST how much he loved her and JUST how little he cared about me. He doted on her... she had a room, and dolls and books and a canopy bed (SO jelly). I had a dusty couch, whatever I brought with me from moms, and a couple of trinkets that he had been forced to purchase.
I don't know how much my sister remembers. She was so little and he hid his dark side from her. I've never asked her and, Dudie... if you are reading this... I never will. I don't want to compare notes. All that matters is that I'm sorry we had to go through that. I love you so much. You are amazing and beautiful and wonderful and my heart would be lost without you. He didn't win. We did. It took a while, but WE WON.
All of this is ancient history. I'm not even sure why I'm writing about it. I haven't spoken to the man since I was in high school. I carry his scars, but I've dealt with most of my anger. I haven't even really thought about him in forever.
Yet... YEEEEET here I am. Struggling with a case of the feels.
I think if I hadn't passed the angry phase maybe I'd just feel happy. Fuck him. He's dead. Burn and rot and piss on your grave and all that, you fucker.
But, I don't. I don't feel happy he's dead. I feel vaguely sad.
My friend suggested today that I was sad because a spark of hope was now extinguished. That I'd kept it locked up tight, but, now that it was taken away from me I was feeling its loss.
My friend is not without smarts.
The truth is there are many reasons I'm feeling weird about this. I haven't had a chance to analyze all of them yet, and maybe I won't ever be able to. But the one I can see clearly is this: I'm sad because I will never get a dad. Not a real one. Not the kind I deserved. I'm sad because it's really truly over. There will be no reunion. He won't tell me he was wrong and that I AM amazing. The little girl in me will never have the dad who hugs and protects and loves her.
It's done. It's really over now.
And... as I've been writing this I've started to realize that can be okay.
My past shaped me. I wouldn't be who I am without it and, frankly, my life today is full of amazing people that I wouldn't trade for the world. The healing strength of the people who don't have to love me, but do far outweighs the pain of a man who was supposed to, but didn't. I am so grateful for that.
So, it's time to work on letting it (and him) go.
Sing me out, Elsa...
Sing me out, Elsa...